A Minority Government

(First published at Israelnationalnews.com)

The selection of Matan Kahana as Knesset speaker pushed through by Arab votes makes it abundantly clear that the Arabs now control the levers of power in Israel. They can make or break governments, politicians, and policies. They have a stranglehold on the left which cannot survive without them. They exploit our democracy and expose its greatest weakness; as Henry Kissinger famously put it, “power is the ultimate aphrodisiac.” That they now have the power, and what others will do to claim titular power, is humiliating to the Jewish state of Israel and dangerous as well.

As such, it seems that the likeliest outcome of the attempt by Gadi Eisenkot’s Yashar Party to assemble a coalition will be a minority government that is hostage to the nineteen votes of the Arab parties, which refuse to label Hamas a terrorist group and is essentially a fifth column within Israel. This would explain why there is no sense of urgency to form a government; a minority government is a given. Other parties could be added to that formation. Everyone is acting, playing their role in a game whose result is already known.

Many people sincerely dream of a national unity government involving Likud and Yashar and a handful of other Zionist parties. From one perspective, in theory, a unity government could make progress on a number of important issues without having to deal with extremes, as well as confront the ongoing security threats facing Israel on multiple fronts. But from another perspective, well, everyone loves “unity,” but policies do matter. What if the two main parties disagree on critical issues? PM Netanyahu staked his career on preventing the development of an Iranian nuclear weapon that could destroy us; Eisnekot said years ago that he is willing to concede an Iranian bomb. What is the middle ground?

Does Eisenkot have an economic policy? Tax policy? Educational policy? Likud represents the more traditional Israel, Eisenkot the more secular Israel. Is there a middle ground on issues of religion and state, beyond maintaining the status quo that elements of the left want to undo? Could such a government label Qatar and Turkey enemy states and halt their funding of Arab organizations that seek to undermine our sovereignty in Jerusalem and elsewhere, not to mention our elections? How would such a government choose the next batch of Supreme Court justices, who control our politics more than does the Knesset, or the next Attorney-General, which is akin to appointing our next dictator?

Unity is a fantasy and maybe a necessary one but it is also a recipe for paralysis. Yet that is not even the main reason a unity government is unlikely. The main reason is that the foremost concern on the left from the beginning of the campaign and even going back well over a decade is simply to get rid of Netanyahu. That is it. Any platform they proffered was just a side show to the main act: Bibi must go! If that is the case, a unity government that retains Netanyahu completely undercuts the principal promise the left made to its voters.

Note that the left (Eisenkot, Lieberman, Bennet) repeatedly, loudly, and explicitly guaranteed to its voters that any government under their leadership would not rely on Arab votes for its existence. Maybe they believed it, maybe they intended it, maybe they were lying even then; the bottom line is that most of their voters simply do not care about that promise if they succeed in their core objective: getting rid of Netanyahu.

It is a mistake for the right wing to harp on the fact that the Knesset, its committee chairs, and the future government hinges on the votes of Arab parties who support terror against Jews. It sounds good, and certainly the sensitivities of the bereaved families, wounded soldiers, and stalwart reservists, horrified by this prospect, warrant validation – but the bigger problem is that this should have been foreseen, and violations of the law prosecuted. The credible reports of widespread cheating in the Arab sector in the recent election, and the quashing of any investigation, are more ominous. There is an even bigger issue. Today the Arabs in Knesset have 19 seats. What if they win 25 in the next election? And 35 in the one after that? If cheating works – ballot stuffing, bribery, fabrication of votes – then of course they will continue to do it, until they have the sufficient mandates to vote the Jewish state of Israel out of existence. What will the Knesset do to stop that – and what can they do if the Attorney-General and Supreme Court would overturn whatever the Knesset did?

It is hypocritical, albeit understandable, that the sane Zionist parties recoil from a Knesset or a government controlled by hostile Arabs because the real problem is a Supreme Court that refuses to enforce the election law that bans parties that reject Israel as a Jewish state and a democracy. These Arab parties openly reject the notion of Israel as a Jewish state and thus have recurrently been banned from running by the Central Elections Committee (even in the most recent elections!) only to be restored to the ballot by our rogue, lawless Supreme Court. Certainly, Arabs supportive of Israel as a Jewish state in which their minority rights are protected, who denounce terror and do not consort with our enemies, should be allowed and encouraged to run. But we have granted our enemies access to our inner sanctum, distorted our laws to enable them, and they have taken full advantage of it.

If a minority government backed by Arabs is the likeliest scenario, then why doesn’t Eisenkot just announce it today? Because he prefers the fig leaf of Haredi parties that can give him a “Jewish” majority of 61. And he knows that if down the road Haredim leave his government for one reason or another – which is bound to happen – he will still have the security blanket provided for him by the Arabs.

That is why he and his partners, in defiance of yet another solemn pledge to their voters, are offering the Haredim exemptions from IDF service, exemptions whose scope and number exceed anything that has been proposed in recent years. And yes – all those voters who sincerely wanted an equal sharing of the burden, and who resented the Haredi exemption, and who punished the Religious Zionist party and Likud at the polls for their failure to conscript the Bnai Yeshivot, all those voters were played for fools, manipulated by a sophisticated and well-funded (mainly from overseas) campaign by cynical politicians.

Suddenly, we are learning that even Avigdor Lieberman no longer believes that everyone must serve and only those who “serve, receive 100%; those who don’t, receive 0%.” Never mind! Suddenly, we are learning that the IDF really doesn’t need more soldiers (except to the extent that every general always wants more soldiers) and intends next year to reduce its manpower and shrink its enlistment. My, how things changed overnight.

The controversy was always mostly political, which doesn’t excuse the Haredi and Yeshivish world from their Torah obligations to the common weal and defense. The question is will they accept the offer? Is the offer even sincere? Will they be hooked into a government some of whose members are openly antagonistic to Israel as a Jewish state and the application of halacha in any area of life? Will they agree to promises of exemptions that the Supreme Court might (should, based on prior rulings) then reject? Will they give the hechsher (seal of approval) to a government that depends on the support of those inimical to our existence and whose policies will weaken our claim to the land of Israel and the observance of the Torah?

If they do, it is shameful, a classic application of the rabbinic dictum that “aveira goreret aveira,” one sin leads to another (Avot 4:2). The sin of spurning the defense of the people and the land of Israel – two fundamental mitzvot – will have engendered the sin of underwriting those who favor dismantling the Jewishness of the state, Shabbat, Kashrut, conversion, marriage and divorce, etc. as well as those who want to eradicate the state itself.

On the other hand, if they don’t, well, then they get nothing – no exemptions, no money, and probably an upward ratcheting of arrests and incarcerations, as well as brutality against protesters and demonstrators.

It is a conundrum that has boxed in Yahadut Hatorah. Decline, and get nothing, or join and get something but sell your principles for a temporary and illusory advantage. And the temptation would then be great for Shas to also join the government, which would then have 61 seats without the Arabs, and share in the spoils – but at what price to Torah, the real, living Torah?

The tacit reliance on Arab support can explain why Naftali Bennett has been so silent (until today) and why Avigdor Lieberman has been so accommodating to the Haredim whose infamy and malignity he proclaimed for decades. Obviously, to be part of a minority Jewish government wholly reliant on radical Arab support violates yet another of their campaign promises, but so what? Worse, it will cripple our ability to fight terror, settle the land of Israel, and arrest the illegal Arab encroachment and building in the Galil and the Negev. We will also have – like much of the West already has – fallen prey to the Muslim Brotherhood guide to the global Islamic revolution: take control of societies from the ground up and then slowly infiltrating their governments, until domination.

A minority Jewish government will facilitate that takeover rather than hinder it.

All this is likely but not inevitable. What can be done to avoid this predicament?

As I see it, there is only one scenario, which might be even less likely to occur although it would solve many issues: PM Netanyahu should offer to step down and the Likud should appoint a successor who would be able to form a government.

Let’s face it. Binyamin Netanyahu has been a most consequential leader of Israel, a world class diplomatic force, and a thought leader. He has many successes to his credit – as well as many failures, primarily among them (not October 7, which would have happened on the watch of any Israeli leader) his utter failure to rein in the unlawful excesses of Israel’s legal and judicial establishments. Sure, he has been the number one target of their corruption, and the bogus cases against him – meant, by their own telling, to drive him out of public life – should never have been brought and should be dismissed forthwith. But he let that problem metastasize, and it has both neutered and consumed him.

In truth, Israel’s political universe has revolved around him for too long, and he is palpably polarizing. There are many people who adore him but many more people who despise him. In his second long tenure as prime minister, he first led the Likud to 28 seats in 2009 – and now to 27 seats in 2026. His base is fixed, as are his antagonists. He gets an increasing number of votes – almost 1.2 million in this election, an increase of 25,000 and more than 250,000 than the next largest party – but a declining percentage in the share of votes, in this election barely 20% of the total vote. That is going backwards.

Most of the opposition is the opposition to him, personally. Most, if not all of these political leaders, are people he appointed to public life – ministers, generals, aides, etc. They loathe him and refuse to collaborate with him or form any government that includes him. It doesn’t matter why or whether it is justified; what matters is that this hatred has become toxic for Israeli society.

To be sure, it would be a great loss for Israel – in terms of our relationship with Donald Trump (who has his own problems these days, bigly) and in the presentation of Israel’s case on the world stage (not that we are so popular in the world). Netanyahu has been an incomparable exponent of Israel’s values and policies and it is hard to imagine who can replace that. But he will be replaced, for no person is indispensable, and his departure will remove the main obstacle – fair or not – to a stable, Jewish government.

If the choice is between an Eisenkot minority-Jewish government beholden to Arabs and a Likud-led government without Netanyahu, then the latter is preferable for a host of reasons. He would retire with dignity and have the gratitude of most of the nation that he served honorably, if imperfectly. That it probably won’t happen is not to say that it shouldn’t happen. It should – but Jews who are “a wise and understanding people” (Devarim 4:6) have not always been known for our common sense or our good decisions.

But “this great nation” (ibid) deserves better and the Jewish state that depends on Arabs for its survival will not be Jewish or a state for long.

Or I could be completely wrong!

The situation is fluid, unpredictable, and the path to any government is serpentine. One can hope that the two leading parties will exhibit maturity and national responsibility and form a broad unity government that includes four or five or six other parties, a government that will focus on our external threats and leave philosophical and constitutional disputes for some time in the future. Or there can be new elections. The choice is theirs. And ours.

Wanted: National Pride

(First published at Israelnationalnews.com)

The walkout by members of the Arab parties from the Knesset plenum during the singing of Hatikvah should outrage every Israeli. It is a slap in the face to the soldiers who protect their freedoms and every citizen who has contributed to the good life they enjoy in the Jewish state, in contrast to the repression and hardship they would experience in any of the twenty-two Muslim paradises that dot the Middle East. It is the epitome of ingratitude and short-sightedness, a breach of the Talmudic norm (Bava Kamma 92b) “do not throw a stone into the well from which you drank.”

The insult should not be ignored because it is an indication of both the political power Israeli Arabs now wield as well as the contempt they have for the Jewish State of Israel whose demise they subtly aid and abet. No nation with any sense of pride should tolerate such disdain, reminiscent of the UN member states – enemies of Israel – who walk out when an Israeli gets up to speak in the General Assembly. I wonder: if an Israeli Arab diplomat were appointed to our UN delegation and got up to speak, would he walk out on himself?

No person who disdains the national anthem or other national symbols should be eligible to serve in the Knesset or receive any benefits from the State. Their emigration should be encouraged as a national priority. But the Arab parties and their voters are indulged because of the lingering guilt of secular Israelis who cannot cogently explain what right they have to be sovereign in the land of Israel, as well as the power the Arab parties now possess.

This power was obtained through their mindboggling success in the recent elections, almost doubling their vote totals from the last election. They achieved a voter turnout of more than 80%, an astounding figure; heretofore, they had never garnered a voter share of even 60% of their electorate and often less than 50%. In their rush to depose Netanyahu and his right-wing government, the ethically-challenged legal and judicial establishments are aggressively ignoring credible evidence of Arab voter fraud, ballot stuffing, blatant voter bribery including the distribution of envelopes of cash and fuel payment cards – all subsidized by our enemies – and violent suppression of authorized poll watchers charged with electoral oversight in Arab communities.

And now, despite their hostility to Israel as a Jewish state, their collusion with all our enemies, and their self-definition as Palestinians, the Arab parties and their nineteen Knesset mandates are being courted by Gadi Eisenkot’s Yashar party, in his efforts to dethrone Netanyahu, either to actively join his proposed government or support it from the outside.

Either way, that gives our domestic enemies a stranglehold over Israeli politics. Consider how the Bennett government was forced to restrain its response to attacks from Gaza in order to placate Mansour Abbas’ Ra’am Party in the last government. Consider also that the recent and future appointments in the Knesset – committee heads and speaker – are all subject to the Arab veto because the left-wing Eisenkot coalition lacks a Jewish majority. This will result inevitably in policies that are inimical to our security and welfare because – make no mistake about it – these parties do not wish us well.

Are the Arab parties being offered items on their wish list in order to give Eisnekot control over the Knesset, items such as autonomy in the Galil and Negev, a blind eye to their illegal building, huge sums of money for their coffers?

From one perspective, the walkout of the Arab parties is unsurprising. After all, the anthem of the State of Israel does not speak to them. They do not share our “Tikvah” (hope) of returning to the land of Israel, the land of Zion and Jerusalem. They do not possess the “Jewish soul that yearns” and “gazes toward Zion.” They barely tolerate living in a Jewish state, if at all; thus, Israeli Arab voices taunted Jews last week with the claim: “This is not your land! We are the rulers here!” Which begs the questions: why are they here? Why do we allow the presence of a fifth column in our midst? Will the ideal of democracy lead to the dismantlement of the Jewish state?

Those who are here are largely descendants of Arabs whose presence in Israel preceded statehood, but not by much, with a majority only immigrating to the land of Israel in the 19th century once the Zionists came and established flourishing businesses, factories, and farms. No one prevents them from leaving if they so choose – and many do choose to leave – but most have not accommodated themselves to the Jewishness of the state. Both current Arab parties openly support the de-Judaizing of the State of Israel, making it a state of all its citizens with nothing Jewish about it. Arab armies need not overwhelm us from the outside if we can be overthrown from the inside.

Many left-wing Israelis are quick to proclaim that Arab citizens are equal and good citizens, who should fully serve in the government and have unfettered access to state secrets and intelligence. Well, that should be put to the test: if universal conscription can apply to Israeli Haredim, it can certainly apply to Israeli Arabs. Draft them into the army.

There have always been subtle objections, as in the reluctance to force Israeli Arabs to fight their co-religionists who are our enemies. That objection sounds plausible but is actually feeble and unconvincing. Millions of American, British, and French Protestants went to war against German Protestants in World War II. Thousands of Indian Muslims serve in the Indian military, even though India is a majority Hindu state and their primary enemy is Muslim Pakistan. That is because they are firstly loyal to their nation and feel a national identity that transcends their religious affiliation.

So why aren’t Israeli Arabs subject to the draft? Let us not hem and haw but state the reason directly: because no one trusts them.

Too many Israeli Arabs (certainly not all) see themselves not as Israelis but as Palestinians. Their parties explicitly declared themselves representative of the Palestinian people and receive guidance and funding from, and coordinate with, the Palestinian Authority. Anti-Jewish terror perpetrated by Israeli Arabs has markedly increased in the last decade and mixed cities like Lod and Ramle have constant friction between Jews and Arabs.

Yes, no one trusts them. Of course, many Bedouin serve with dedication and distinction, as do other Israeli Gentiles like the Druze and Circassians. But Israeli Arabs in the army might more likely use their weapons on their fellow soldiers than against our enemies. They may not want to live in the PA – who would? – even though they have every right to move there and live in a majority Muslim jurisdiction. They prefer to live in Israel – but like with the mentality of the suicide bomber, they prefer to live in an Israel that they can slowly dismantle and then destroy, from within.

Yes, no one trusts them in the army. So how can they be trusted in government, in the cabinet, in the Foreign Affairs and Defense Committee of the Knesset? How can we counter the nefarious influences of Qatar and Turkey when the vehicles of that influence are often these same political parties?

Israel prides itself on being both a democracy and a Jewish state, and now those two are colliding. In theory, both can co-exist. In practice, the Arabs are playing the game of democracy in order to “democratize” the Jewish state into oblivion. This, indeed, is not unique to Israel. The same process is underway throughout Western democracies, such as the United States, Britain, France, and elsewhere. The objective is to attain power through democracy – in order to end it and transform those countries beyond the point of recognition. And in each case, Muslims are spearheading the effort.

Note how Israeli law bans anyone from running for the Knesset who rejects Israel as either a Jewish state or a democracy. Basic Law (7A) bars participation of anyone who negates the existence of the State of Israel as a Jewish and democratic state, incites to racism, and/or expresses support for an armed struggle by an enemy state, or of a terrorist organization, against the State of Israel.

How, then, can it be, that people who reject Israel as a Jewish state, express support for terror, refuse to condemn Hamas or even define those savage murderers as a terrorist group, how can it be that they are allowed to run for the Knesset? The answer is that they have been banned several times by the Central Elections Committee, only to be restored to the ballot due to the stunning corruption of Israel’s Supreme Court, which routinely flouts standing laws, fabricates others as it wishes, and holds itself above the laws that bind the rest of us. Only Jews have been banned by the Court; even in this round, when the Court considered banning Sami Abou Shahadeh, number three on the Joint List, for his pro-terror statements, in its fecklessness the Court just allowed him to withdraw. But how different is Sami Abou Shahadeh from others on the Joint List?

US Supreme Court Justice Robert Jackson famously opined that the Constitution (he actually referred to the Bill of Rights) “is not a suicide pact.” Our political ideals cannot be so disconnected from reality that those ideals will invariably lead to our demise.

Thomas Jefferson expressed it even more clearly: “A strict observance of the written law is doubtless one of the high duties of a good citizen, but it is not the highest. The laws of necessity, of self-preservation, of saving our country when in danger, are of higher obligation. To lose our country by a scrupulous adherence to the written law, would be to lose the law itself, with life, liberty, property and all those who are enjoying them with us; thus absurdly sacrificing the ends to the means.”

We are at an inflection point in Israeli society. What political scientists term “defensive democracy” allows democracy to defend its institutions from those who would exploit them to destroy democracy itself. It is what justifies otherwise undemocratic notions such as banning candidates who reject Israel as either a democracy or a Jewish state. It is what the left hopes to do in proposing legislation that will effectively bar Netanyahu from running again. But “defensive democracy” is indefensible and immoral when it only constrains Jews and not Arabs, when its legislation is applied selectively and unfairly, and when it undermines democratic norms without saving democracy itself.

Those who cannot tolerate Hatikvah cannot tolerate that Jews have returned to our homeland after a long exile. They certainly abhor the prophetic vision of the return of the Jewish people as divinely ordained. If they cannot endure that simple reality, they should not serve in the Knesset. If they cannot be trusted to serve the public interest, then frankly, they should not be here altogether. Obviously, any Arab who fully accepts living in a Jewish state is entitled to full civil rights and fair and equal treatment but judging by their voting patterns (for extremist parties) that number is not substantial.

How we execute that national objective should be paramount in our strategic planning for the future. We should not sacrifice the sovereign Jewish state on the altar of democracy. The warning signs are flashing.

R.I.P. MAGA

(First published at Israelnationalnews.com)

The harshest appurtenance in any home is usually the mirror, which never lies. Let us hope the White House has several into which President Trump can gaze and reflect. His efforts to shift blame for the Republicans’ catastrophic defeat in the midterm elections from himself to anyone or anything else are vacuous, even comical. Most presidents similarly situated have accepted responsibility for the fate of their party. Not this one. Surely, he who for years touted the victories of politicians he endorsed (even when they ran unopposed) could endeavor some explanation of why his endorsements backfired this time.

According to Mr. Trump, why were the Republicans routed?

The war was unpopular. The war was unpopular, albeit necessary, but it was the flawed conduct of the war that made it unpopular. Trump was simply incapable of conveying to the American people the importance of the war for the United States and for the world. Israeli political scientist Gadi Taub said this week that “Trump’s policies are those of a seasoned politician, but the way he communicates them is that of a child in kindergarten.”

The war became unpopular because Trump kept promising that it would be over in a “week,” “two weeks,” “no more than a month,” before or after the midterms, that the US had completely destroyed Iran’s army, navy, and missile capacity (even as they kept harassing ships) when the US had not, and that Iran “wanted a deal badly” (when they weren’t even negotiating). Trump apparently never considered that Iran would mine and close the Straits of Hormuz, which any elementary Pentagon war game would have suggested as a likely response. But Trump has no need of experts. Hence the stalemate and the unpopularity of the war.

Trump challenged Iran, emboldened tens of thousands of Iranians to protest the regime because “help is on the way,” but it wasn’t they were slaughtered. He then had Iran on the ropes after Israel’s aerial assault and let them off, lacking the killer’s instinct but possessing the bully’s certainty that his victim will soon capitulate. But the ideologue will never surrender to the bully. Trump blinked. If the war was unpopular, Trump’s conduct of it made it so.

The Republican candidates were ineffective. But Trump hand selected so many of them! He torpedoed the campaign of incumbent Jon Cornyn of Texas, and he foisted the novice Darline Graham on South Carolina. And others. In Cornyn’s place, Trump championed an unpopular, ethically challenged scoundrel who at least was loyal to him. These were his people, and to run from that is shameless. The MAGA movement turns out to have been little more than a personality cult, and when the people turned on the cult leader and dissented from certain policy choices, the charade was revealed. He can blame the candidates – but the mirror also has whom to blame.

And to assume all is going well because his rallies are well attended is narcissistic and shallow. The rallies were entertainment, often devoid of substance, boring a second time, and what made news was usually some silly comment about people’s body parts.

“If I was on the ballot, we would have won in a landslide like the last three elections.” Well, it is true Trump wasn’t on the ballot but he campaigned as if he was. Otherwise, why campaign? But – shouldn’t someone be challenging him on this? – Trump has never won a single landslide. He barely lost the popular vote in 2016, he lost the popular vote and the electoral college in 2020 (if there is any evidence to the contrary, he should adduce it), and squeaked to victory in 2024, winning the popular vote for the first time but still garnering less the 50% of the total vote. Landslide? Hardly, unless you just redefine the word.

In 2026, Trump was a drag on the ticket. By January, elected Republicans will be running from him if they hope to advance in 2028.

Fox News interviewed the opposition. This should not even require a response. A media organization that serves the public should present diverse viewpoints to its audience. (This is a lesson that Israel’s channels 11, 12, and 13 could learn.)

It is Israel’s fault. This is one of JD Vance’s contributions to the analysis, stopping just short of saying that Israel dragged the US into war, which is the contention of some Vance allies. History should not forget that Israel fought alone for the first eleven days of the twelve-day war, and once air superiority was won, the US sent its long-range bomber to strafe the nuclear facilities. It was then that Trump foolishly decided to stop the war – on the cusp of victory.

President Trump inadvertently strengthened Vance’s argument by blurting out on Election Day Eve that he will no longer “give Israel $4 billion a year.” Well, this notion should be parsed and properly understood. The $4B the US purports to “give” to Israel is 0.000571% of the annual US budget, and less than half a percent of Israel’s budget. (The US spends three times as much maintaining its military bases in Germany eighty years after World War II ended and in Korea seventy years after the Korean War ended.)

It is certainly appreciated – but the following is not well understood, not by our enemies in America, and perhaps not even by Trump.

The $4B is not “given” to Israel. Israel is given a credit of $4B that can only be spent in the US purchasing American weapons. It is not $4B in cash that Israelis spend on falafel but the $4B is actually “given” to Boeing, Lockheed Martin, Caterpillar, and the other 250 American defense contractors who rely on this money and employ thousands of Americans. Some of those companies have present contracts with Israel and are expecting this subsidy to continue.

Israel would be better off without this perception – but that should also come at a price.

As Ambassador Yoram Ettinger frequently points out, the US’s investment for the $4B annual credit is repaid 1000%. For example, a decade ago the USAF’s F-35 was considered a dead letter, unworkable, and unsellable because of design flaws. Congress almost mothballed it – but then Israel bought a fleet, redesigned it, removed the flaws, upgraded and refined it, and shared that information with the United States which incorporated that into their production. That’s a savings of multi-billion dollars in research and development, just from one vehicle, far more than Israel receives. Add to that, multiple American weapons systems that Israel has refined and improved.

Additionally, Israel provides the US invaluable intelligence in the region, as Israel does to European countries, some that are openly hostile to Israel. Well, an alliance is bilateral. Israelis do not mind the cessation of the American subsidy, and as PM Netanyahu suggested, prefers joint investments in R & D. But the US should then be prepared to pay Israel fair market value for our expertise and refinement of their weapons, as well for the intelligence we provide that saves American lives.

Indeed, the image of Israel as a hapless mendicant hurts us. The image of Israel as a proud ally helps us. A partnership suits us fine – but do not blame Israel for your mismanagement of your end of the war.

Affordability. There really is little an American president can do to lower prices except maintain supplies but he can make unforced errors that raise prices, which include, aside from the Iran War’s temporary hike, the ill-advised tariffs that – despite Trump’s bluster – has brought in relatively little revenue but upset the markets and raised the cost of living. And his boasts that “America is the hottest country in the world,” “greatest economy in American history,” “with “tens of trillions of dollars in foreign investment,” none of that is true. And people know that.

For sure, Trump erred in repeatedly referencing his vanity projects (ballroom, reflecting pool, golf courses) to people struggling to pay their bills. But he probably doesn’t see that.

The MAGA movement is over, held together by force of personality. Its former adherents now disagree vehemently on various policy positions, including Israel. Congress is likely to be paralyzed, allowing Democrats to run in 2028 on the need for a president who is aligned with Congress. And they will prevail, even if Congress spends its time impeaching Trump and investigating his family for their grifting.

One point not covered that also heralds the demise of MAGA is the reconfiguration of the American electorate. The last decades have seen out-migration from Democratic states which have become unlivable for a variety of reasons (high cost of living, high taxes, high crime rate). Millions of Americans have left blue strongholds like California, New York, New Jersey, and Illinois to live in red states like Texas, North and South Carolina, and Florida.

Guess what? They brought their politics with them. No surprise then that these red states all elected Democratic senators, governors, and representatives – and Florida’s Republicans just barely squeaked by. There has been a dramatic shift in population distribution. And the migration is one way – no one wants to live in the liberal paradises so America will look bluer and bluer and less welcoming to Israel.

Trump did so much for Israel and his rise to power so preposterous that it is impossible to see him as anything other than a providential gift. He was a messenger. He has a natural affinity for Israel that will become increasingly rare in American politics in the years ahead. We thank him and pray that he does nothing impulsively to undo his contributions of the last decade. His era is over. His MAGA movement is dead.

What isn’t? Am Yisrael Chai.

Friends Like This  

(First published at Israelnationalnews.com)

The explosive rise of Jew hatred across the world and even in the United States should not obscure one curious fact, drawn from the lives of three of the most prominent Jew haters in America. Granted, there is a healthy competition for that designation, but for our purposes we can focus on Abdul El Sayed, the Senator-elect from Michigan, Zohran Mamdani the Mayor of New York City, and Hassan Piker the streamer and media gadfly.

What do all three have in common, aside from their pathological obsession with Israel and hatred of Jews? The roots of all three are not from countries that were enemies of Israel but, ostensibly, countries with which Israel has friendly or at least civil diplomatic relations.

Abdul El Sayed was born in Michigan in 1984 to parents who left Egypt in the 1970’s, around the time or perhaps shortly before Egypt and Israel signed a peace treaty. It would seem obvious that his parents opposed the peace treaty, especially considering that – as widely reported – his mother was a member of the Muslim Brotherhood while in college in Egypt. That would be the same Muslim Brotherhood that opposed Anwar Sadat’s diplomatic initiative, the same Muslim Brotherhood whose members were largely incarcerated by Sadat, and the same Muslim Brotherhood that was responsible for Sadat’s assassination. The fact that El Sayed was born into Egyptian citizenship at a time when Egypt was at “peace” with Israel, recognized Israel’s existence, and had no territorial claims against Israel did not make a whit of difference to the El Sayed clan.

Zohran Mamdani was born in 1991 in Uganda to Muslim parents who hailed from India. While he was a child in Uganda, that country established diplomatic relations with Israel. While India-Israel relations then were not as warm as they have been during Prime Minister Modi’s tenure since 2014, those two countries even then had extensive diplomatic and commercial ties. None of his associative countries (Uganda and India) and then the USA, where he grew up in Manhattan from age seven, have any inherent reason to be anti-Israel or anti-Jewish. The first two have miniscule Jewish populations and the third – the USA – speaks for itself. There is no logical reason he would be raised to hate Jews and Israel. His environment alone should have nurtured him to be neutral or supportive.

Hassan Piker was born in New Jersey in 1991 to Turkish parents but was raised in Istanbul during the 1990’s, years before the rise of the Jew-hating Turkish prime minister and then president Recep Tayyip Erdoğan. Piker was raised in a Turkey that prided itself since 1948 on being the only Muslim country that had diplomatic relations with Israel, a Turkey that had a secular government and whose citizens were relatively sophisticated and modern. Was Piker radicalized by Erdoğan’s rise to power in 2003? Or did it emerge from another source – the same source that turned his uncle Cenk Uygur into another rabid Jew hater?

It emerges that none of the countries that produced these fanatical haters should have been fertile ground for their intense hatred. These were not countries that scorned Israel – like Syria, Iraq, Saudi Arabia, Libya, and others; these were countries that maintained extensive relations with Israel, one of which even entered into a peace treaty with Israel. What gives?

One obvious common denominator that in our haste to be politically correct we tend to overlook is that the three are all Muslims. There is a strain of virulent Jew hatred that runs through the Koran and has shaped the attitudes of many, though not all, Muslims. It is a hatred that has little to do with Israel as it long predates the existence of the State of Israel – a hatred that is only ameliorated when Jews are perceived as second class citizens in a Muslim society and a hatred that will never accept a sovereign Jewish state of Israel. Never.

For sure, there are Muslim nations that have reconciled themselves to Israel’s existence, some friendlier than others. And it is true that a cold peace is better than a hot war. But we would be remiss not to note something that our leaders should internalize, especially leaders that situate themselves on the political left. Israel has not signed peace treaties – with, say, Egypt and Jordan – as much as we have signed “absence of war” treaties. We may not fight on the battlefield (a good thing per se) but there is no reconciliation or even warmth from the Arab populations of those countries to us. Jews do not visit Jordan or Egypt in large numbers – and certainly Egyptians or Jordanians do not come here.

The United Arab Emirates were different – but even there, these days, Jewish identity has gone underground. In most Arab countries, even those with formal relations with Israel, those ties are governmental and commercial. Friendship towards Jews or Israel has not seeped into the population, something generally conceded by the leaders of those countries who fear a popular uprising if association with Israel become too open or amicable. Even if they wanted to – not at all a given – internal constraints would prevent them, what the West often calls the “Arab Street.” It is not that the “Arab Street” has any real sway in the dictatorships where those “Streets” are paved; it is rather that the “Arab Street” is an accurate reflection of the societies and cultures that produce execrable Jew haters like El Sayed, Mamdani, and Piker.

Of course, one need not hail from one of these countries to hate Jews or even be a Muslim (take that, Tucker Carlson) and there are plenty of pseudo-Jews of the Bernie Sanders variety who fit the bill and provide (flimsy) cover for the Muslim Jew haters. But it should call into question the value of these “peace treaties” that do not at all make peace between nations. At least the desultory and sporadic efforts to create some diplomatic framework between Israel and Saudi Arabia has the good sense to refer to it as “normalization” rather than “peace.” To concede anything substantive in order to sign an “absence of war” agreement with a country with whom we are not at war is foolhardy.

It makes no difference to the citizens of these countries whether they have treaties or relations with Israel or are openly hostile to Israel. Given the persistence of Jew hatred among the populations of our enemies, and of many countries with which we have diplomatic relations, and in European nations that are being overrun and transformed by their Muslim invaders, what lessons can be gleaned from this sorry state of affairs?

Nothing we do will change their minds. There is no constellation of governmental coalitions, no policies, and no concessions that will dilute their Jew hatred, short of our own dissolution. Their Jew hatred is inbred. Their opposition to Israel is not based on Netanyahu’s leadership or the conduct of the war in Gaza or Lebanon but simply a function of our existence. Yes, sadly, they have revived the argument that Israel, alone among the nations, has no right to exist or one that is debatable.

And we must beware of their infiltration into Western society. These haters are already dominant in Britain, France, and Spain, and are increasingly influential in the US. It would have been inconceivable even a decade ago that unabashed Jew haters such as our three protagonists could have achieved such influence in American politics or culture. Part of their success comes from the pervasiveness of social media, part from the fecklessness of the traditional media, and part from the craven shamelessness of some Jewish politicians and celebrities in the US who run from their Jewish identity, think they will be spared when the day of reckoning comes, and provide them with political cover. The haters are skillfully leveraging the freedoms of democracy to make those countries less democratic and more antagonistic to Israel.

Our election results uncover the same stunt going on here, with open haters of the Jewish State of Israel serving in the Knesset, and potentially dominating, even if from the outside, our own government. Are there politicians willing to mortgage our future by empowering the Arabs all in order to gain for themselves positions of power? Yes, plenty, who will do it gladly.

It seems we are no more successful in combatting the enemy within than are Europe or the United States. When democracy works – i.e., when elections turn out results favorable to them – or when governments implement policies favorable to them, Muslims embrace it enthusiastically. And when it doesn’t, as they see it, they take to the streets and riot and plunder, as is happening in Western Europe.

Our three protagonists, and so many other Jew haters, grew up in democracies, and yet the values of democracy – of liberty, tolerance, equality – have never impacted their world view. The fact that all three live in the United States and their open Jew hatred doesn’t hamper but actually boosts their careers should be an eye opener for American Jews. The Jewish moment in the US is over, with Florida the last refuge. Our final stop in exile is going the way of all previous exiles but at least Jews today have the means of escape and a homeland that beckons.

Days ahead will surely be challenging, but we can meet this challenge by strengthening ourselves spiritually, fortifying ourselves politically, and inculcating in our society the Jewish ethos, our just rights to the land of Israel, and our unwillingness to eviscerate ourselves, our land, or our State to satisfy their insatiable demands.

The West is collapsing. Democracy itself is under siege across the world from within. Our enemies know how to exploit it in order to destroy it. Appreciation of what Jews have brought to the world is waning. Our future lies in our reassertion of the Jewish idea, in pride in our heritage, in faith in our G-d, and in confidence in our destiny.